April 2, 2003
by Joretta Purdue
WASHINGTON - Tents filled the small yard at the
United Methodist Building, providing support for the rally under
way across the street at the Supreme Court.
Inside the courthouse, the justices were to hear
arguments in two cases - Grutter vs. Bollinger and Gratz vs. Bollinger
- concerning affirmative action in University of Michigan admissions
policies. The court's decision, expected this summer, will have
implications for affirmative-action policies nationwide.
Police lined up to keep the rally participants
on the sidewalk, but the crowd grew to fill the four-lane street.
Thousands had traveled great distances to express concern about
the potential erosion of affirmative action.
The April 1 rally, sponsored by the NAACP, drew
appearances by people such as Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.), U.S.
Rep. John Lewis (D-Ga.) and the Rev. Al Sharpton, as well as several
United Methodist Church executives.
Jim Winkler, chief executive of the Board of
Church and Society, pointed to the denomination's strong stand in
support of affirmative action.
"It is an intentional effort to ensure that racial
and ethnic minorities and women of all colors have the chance to
receive all the benefits of our society including education, employment
and housing," Winkler said in a statement. "The church believes
affirmative action opens doors so that all persons will have the
opportunity to pursue the American dream."
The board, which owns the United Methodist Building,
together with the denomination's Commission on Religion and Race
and the Washington Office of Public Policy, Women's Division of
the Board of Global Ministries, joined in welcoming the rally, which
spilled into adjoining streets and continued throughout the morning.
The previous night, hundreds of college students wrapped in blankets
had held a vigil in front of the court.
"Affirmative action has been incorrectly labeled
as giving preferential treatment to people of color who are often
less qualified," said the Rev. Chester Jones in his statement. Jones
is the chief executive of the Commission on Religion and Race. "In
reality, as admissions and employment decisions are being made,
race and ethnicity are one of many considerations." Other factors,
including academic achievement, athletic abilities and family history,
are also considered in such decisions, he said.
"The vast majority of affirmative action programs
do not consider unqualified applicants in the same pool as qualified
applicants but rather consider candidates who are very similarly
qualified," Jones said.
Although affirmative action is perceived as harmful
to white men, "white men hold structural power in society today,"
he said. "According to a Washington Post study, the vast majority
of corporate executives, political officeholders, tenured professors
(and) even small-business owners are white men."
The number of white people who have entered the
nation's 10 most elite institutions of higher education through
alumni preference is higher than the number of blacks and Hispanics
who have entered through affirmative action, Jones said.
"Creating a society of opportunity for all people
is what is at stake in the Michigan affirmative action case," he
asserted. "Institutionalized segregation of the past and present
still requires the remedy of affirmative action to provide opportunity
where opportunities have been and still are being denied."
Jones urged United Methodists in their conference
commissions on religion and race to encourage colleges and universities
in their areas to value racial diversity in admission policies.
He suggested monitoring how church-related institutions work for
a diverse student body.
He observed that 11 historically black colleges
and universities are related to the United Methodist Church. They
were founded in a day when black students were denied admission
to most colleges. "Black institutions still lead in educating the
black community largely because racism still plagues society," he
said.
"Given the misconceptions that abound in the
debate over affirmative action, there are several reasons why we,
as United Methodists, should continue to stand strong in our support
of affirmative action," Jones said.
Both men pointed to the denomination's resolution
on affirmative action - No. 150 in the 2000 Book of Resolutions.
It says, in part, "No persons - whatever their gender, their ethnic
or racial heritage, their physical condition - should be deprived
of pursuing their education or employment aspirations to the full
extent of their talents and abilities."
United Methodist News Service
Joretta Purdue is United Methodist News Service's Washington news
director.
|